Want to cut down on your car insurance costs? If you’re renting and don’t drive much, or if you drive fewer miles annually, pay-per-mile car insurance could be the budget-friendly answer you’ve been looking for. Instead of a one-size-fits-all policy, this type of insurance charges you based on how much you actually drive. Makes sense, right?
In this guide, we’ll walk you through how pay-per-mile car insurance works, why it’s renter-friendly, and how to find the best option for your lifestyle. Whether you walk, bike, catch the train, or use other forms of public transportation, you may already be driving less and could benefit from this insurance model. According to the Federal Highway Administration, the average American drives about 13,500 miles per year, so renters who drive fewer miles stand to save the most. No corporate jargon, we promise.
If you’re like many renters, your car doesn’t get daily action. Maybe you walk, bike, or catch the train more often. Maybe you work from your couch. Whatever the case, traditional car insurance doesn’t care — it charges a fixed monthly rate whether you drive 5 miles or 500.
That’s where pay-per-mile insurance comes in. You pay a monthly base rate (for example, $30/month), plus a per mile rate for each mile you drive. If you barely use your car, you pay way less. This is a rate based model, where your premiums fluctuate depending on your actual mileage. Simple.
On average, pay-per-mile insurance comes out to about $55/month — way more affordable than the typical $192/month for standard car insurance. With a traditional policy, you pay fixed base rates regardless of how much you drive, while pay-per-mile insurance offers more flexible coverage options tailored to your needs. That’s a win for your wallet, especially if you’re watching every dollar.
Here’s the deal: pay-per-mile insurance tracks the actual miles driven using driving data collected through a device installed in your car or an app on your phone. This driving data is used by the insurer to calculate your monthly bill.
Let’s say your cost is made up of a $30 daily base rate (or daily rate) plus 5¢ per mile. If you drive 500 miles in a month, your bill is $55. If you only have 200 miles driven, you pay $40. Your premiums can fluctuate based on the number of mile driven each month.
Most per-mile rates range from 4 to 8 cents. So if your driving varies month to month, your insurance adjusts with you. Renters with unpredictable or low mileage can avoid paying for coverage they’re barely using.
.png)
Not everyone will benefit from this type of insurance — but if you nod along to any of the below, it might be your perfect match:
Think: college students living near campus, retirees who don’t drive often, families with a second “just in case” vehicle. If your car’s more of a backup plan than a daily driver, pay-per-mile can seriously cut your costs.
Only a handful of pay per mile insurers currently operate in the market. Several insurance companies offer mileage-based plans. Some of the big names include:
These insurers offer different plans, and each insurance company or company may provide various coverage types, including liability, comprehensive, and collision coverage. However, there is limited availability in most states, so you’ll want to check what’s offered where you live.
Pro tip: Some companies give discounts when you bundle policies. If you’ve got renters insurance with the same provider, you might score extra savings.
Here’s where it gets real:
Let’s say you have a $34 base rate and pay 5¢ per mile. If you drive 800 miles in a month, your total is $74 — still far cheaper than most standard policies. For example, if your pay-per-mile plan has a 1,000-mile monthly cap and you exceed it by 100 miles, you may be charged an additional $5 for those extra miles.
Premiums are typically paid automatically after each billing cycle, with the amount deducted from your prepaid account or credit card based on your actual mileage.
Your exact savings will depend on a few things: where you live, your driving record, and the insurer’s pricing model. Compared to a traditional auto policy, pay-per-mile insurance can offer significant savings for low-mileage drivers, but other factors—like coverage options, deductibles, and customer satisfaction—can also influence your total cost. That’s why shopping around and running the numbers is worth it.
.png)
Let’s break it down:
Pros:
Cons:
Due to privacy concerns or other drawbacks, some renters may want to steer clear of pay-per-mile insurance.
Make sure you’re comfortable with the tech part — especially how your miles get tracked — before you commit.
Finding the right pay-per-mile plan doesn’t have to be a pain. Here’s what to do:
This isn’t a one-size-fits-all thing, so pick what fits your lifestyle best.
If this model isn’t your thing, don’t worry — there are other ways to save on car insurance:
There’s no one “right” way to lower your bill — it’s all about what works for your situation.
If you’re a renter who doesn’t drive much, pay-per-mile car insurance can be a super smart way to save money. It tailors your monthly rate to your actual driving habits, so you're not overpaying for a car that sits parked most of the week.
Compare providers, crunch the numbers, and decide if it makes sense for you. And if it doesn’t? That’s cool too — there are still plenty of ways to lower your insurance costs.
How does pay-per-mile insurance track my mileage?
Usually through a plug-in device near the steering wheel or a smartphone app. Some companies also accept monthly odometer photos.
Who benefits most from this type of insurance?
Renters who drive less than 10,000 miles a year — remote workers, transit riders, occasional drivers.
How much can I save?
Potentially up to 40% compared to traditional car insurance. The average cost is around $55/month, versus $192 for a regular policy.
What are the downsides?
You’ll have to be okay with your driving being tracked. Plus, availability varies, and not all companies offer flexible payment options.
How do I choose the right one?
Compare quotes, review what tech they use for tracking, and factor in your monthly mileage.
